Trade grades Juan Soto: Padres earned an “A” for landing star; Low scores for citizens despite the great distances

Padres and the Nationals agreed on the biggest deal of the summer hours before Tuesday’s deadline, as San Diego defense star Juan Soto and first baseman Josh Bell scored. In turn, Washington receives Luke Voight and a handful of young players: short CJ Abrams, Mackenzie Gore, players Robert Hassell III and James Wood, and right-back Yarleen Susanna.

The Padres used to get out of the splash action during AJ Preller’s tenure as general manager. This is the biggest, as it ties San Diego with a 23-year-old nether who is on the Hall-of-Fame track and under team control for two more seasons. For their part, the Citizens welcome a number of young players, a few of whom may become greats in Washington. They are now advancing, likely under new ownership, without the possibility of competition for at least a few years.

Here at CBS Sports we’re nothing if not judgmental, and that means providing near-instant analysis on the big trades this time of year. Below, you’ll find scores for both the Padres and Nationals, along with explanations for those ratings.

That way away, let’s start by summarizing the deal:

receive badres

Citizens receive

  • 1B Lok Voight
  • SS CJ Abrams
  • LHP Mackenzie Gor
  • Robert Hassell III
  • James Wood
  • RHB Garlin Susanna

Padres score: A

Professional baseball is, at its core, part of the entertainment industry. We try to overlook this reality most of the time on the grounds that we want baseball to be something greater, or more. Accepting the idea that baseball is part of the entertainment industry isn’t a bad thing, and it doesn’t include those romantic feelings. No one has ever held it against movies or music. Recognizing baseball as entertainment above all else, and stripping dogmatic devotion to it as something greater, only becomes a problem when you don’t find the product amusing.

Padres fans were there and they did. They spent the summer watching a lifeless producer who was fronted by Chris Denorphia, Will Venable, and Chase Headley in their memorable generic outfit. We don’t mean to disrespect this trio of players, but you can sympathize with any Padres fans who pinch themselves today, knowing they’ll be coming in in the fall to see a powerful trio of Manny Machado and Fernando Tatis Jr. and Juan Soto. (They’ll wear Technicolor shirts, too.)

No executive seems to understand and appreciate the entertainment side of things more than AJ Preller. Say what you will about his trades and techniques (and other teams make fun of his free ways all the time) but the guy knows how to energize his fan base by making flashy moves involving big names, all in the quest to win the first world series in franchise history.

Whether the Padres achieve this goal or not – and they seem more apt to do so than ever before – they are sure to enjoy trying, and will sell plenty of tickets and merchandise along the route.

Soto is one of the best hitters and as such he is one of the best in the majors. To make the point, it’s having its worst season (as judged by OPS+) in the pandemic era. It still hits .246/.408/.485 with a much more walk than hits. If your “lows” take you down 40.8 percent of the time And the a .240 ISO… So, friends, this is proof that you are dealing with elite talent. soto is; There’s a reason people keep sticking around names like Ted Williams when they discuss his place in the game.

For those who haven’t enjoyed watching Soto play constantly, he does whatever you want on the board. He has excellent command in the strike zone; He has good ball-handling skills, which allows him to connect at above-average rates; And his barrel realization is that he consistently posted average exit velocities that rank near the top of the league. The only real hit on Soto is that his defense is often sub-par, but that’s a trivial issue considering his attack.

Adding Soto to an already good roster of up to three playoff rounds is the kind of opportunity that doesn’t come up often. It’s the kind of high-leverage maneuver where any cost is justified, even if it often means emptying the rest of your farm system. The Padres did like this here, although they were able to hold on to some interesting youngsters, including catcher Luis Camposano and player Jackson Merrill. Again, the cost almost pays for itself when you get a Soto-caliber player for several years. obtained by Badris more It’s hard to understand ‘Soto’ here – and ‘more’ is another good player needed… well, jeez.

Bill is an imminent free agent and represents a clear upgrade over Eric Hosmer. In 103 games this season, he has made .301/.384/.493 (152 OPS+) with 14 home runs and 12 short runs (69). It’s not every day you add a racket that can hit average, walk and sprint — the Padres added two on Tuesday, giving them a deeper, more powerful lineup for what will likely be an October gauntlet.

However, there is no guarantee that the Padres will progress beyond the wild card round. It’s a top three series, and there are weird things going on in a three-game series all the time in the sport. But it seems that whenever baseball players invoke probability analysis these days, it is to justify standing or standing. Our team only got 20% in the playoffs, what were we supposed to do? What Preller seems to be saying instead is: What if we treat the possibilities as a reference, not as a guide; Nothing guarantees that numbers will be a reality like teams treat them as one. Both the Los Angeles Dodgers and the New York Mets have a lot of influencer talent, the only way to beat that is by using your influence talent. The Padres have their share now, and it’s all thanks to Preller.

It may work, it may not. Give Brillair that much: Baseball has been a much funnier game, in San Diego and elsewhere, because of him.

Citizen degree: D

It does not matter who the citizens received in exchange for Soto. you did not. The truth is, you really lose out if you find yourself trading a 23-year-old on the Hall-of-Fame track who still has several more years of team control. History supports the idea that it is impossible to get equal value to a player of Soto’s caliber, and it seems unlikely that this deal will be an exception, even if some of the returning youngsters go on to land strong or better jobs. As it sometimes needs to be stated explicitly: This score is a reflection of the current situation, where the face of the franchise is replaced amid these circumstances, more so than the players.

The most generous reading of this deal is that Lerners, who are selling the franchise, have been hurt by Soto’s merchandising relationships so the next owners can enter with a clean slate. How kind. The subscript—which Lerners realizes that the following owners won’t want to extend Soto, either—should not be lost on anyone. (Remember that whole talk about how baseball is part of the entertainment industry? That’s the other side of it.) You have to feel for general manager Mike Rizzo. Do you think he memorized his farewell letter now? Bryce Harper, Anthony Rendon, Max Scherzer, Tria Turner, and now Soto. It all went away in a few years.

Voit, 31, is the most accomplished player the Citizens have had, even if it was Plan B after Eric Hosmer objected to his inclusion in the deal. Voit has two more seasons of team control remaining and will serve an immediate purpose as a useful replacement for Bale. He is an above average hitter with good strength and a willingness to walk. Voit’s strike rate has risen over the past two years, suggesting that citizens may want to move it this winter before its floor goes down.

Almost actual headlines by default, Abrams and Gore have lived near the top of potential client lists for years, and they’ve both appeared in majors ever since. However, each of them had a difficult and understandable introduction to the big league match.

Abrams, 21, is a short-range hitter of .325/.285/.320 (77 OPS+) with 23 more strokes than walking on his first 139 runs to the plate. He is not far from detention as a reason for Fernando Tates Jr.. He’ll take over from Shortstop, which talks about how the Padres and the industry viewed him. It can be hard to reconcile that assessment with his play in the majors, but it’s worth noting that Padres was quick to make his arrival. He had made just 42 appearances over the A-ball when he made his league debut, and that came before suffering a leg injury at the end of the season last summer.

Some evaluators have expressed concern about Abrams’ sloppy decisions and communication quality in the past. These concerns seem prescient thus far: His chase rate was more than 40 percent and he had an average exit velocity in the mid-1980s. Not perfect. The question is whether or not Abrams can settle down as he gains some much-needed experience against high-level competition. We are willing to hold on to the hope that the answer is yes, which in turn will make him the owner of a high-quality short service in a timely manner.

Gore, 23, has played 16 games (most starts) and accumulated a 4.50 ERA (84 ERA+ and a 1.95 hit-to-walk ratio before recently entering the afternoon elbow injury list. He’s not likely to play again until September, and the Nationals will be within reason. to close it for the year and allow it to start over the next spring.

Gore was in a position to score any rounds in the big league this season was a win in itself, as he signaled a victory over a clear game with the lottery – an extension of often inexplicable brutality. The Padres used him out of the game late in his sojourn with the team, but he has a full arsenal – a mid-’90s fastball and signature curveball that stands out as his best showing, plus a rarely used passer – and they should have a chance to start moving forward.

The catch with Gore is that the combination of his current injury and past brutality makes it difficult to predict his future with any real accuracy. It can be a starter in the middle of the turn, and it can be more or less depending on how things go.

Hassell Wood are both outside and newly selected players.

Hassell, 21 in less than two weeks, expects to have a good tool. He had yet to utilize his raw strength in the way that scouts wanted to see from him since he went to first place. 8 overall in 2020, and it is unclear whether he will remain central in the long term. If Hassell slips into a corner, that puts more pressure on him to pop open.

Wood, 19, a second-round pick last summer, is listed at 6-foot-7. He has tremendous superhuman strength and moves better than you’d expect for someone this size. Residents had concerns about his tendency to swing and miss as an amateur, but he made gains in that department. This season in A-ball, he’s made less than 20 percent of his trips to the plate. There is a possibility in the middle of the lineup here if Wood can keep the racket on the ball constantly as he moves up the ladder.

18-year-old Susanna is the big right-hander who has never offered a higher bid than the complex league. He has a good fastball and a promising ball. There is a chance that it will turn into a high-quality jug, the basic building blocks are present; There is also a chance that he will turn into an assistant, or never give presentations in majors. So it goes with complex arms.

These additions leave Citizens with an improved farm system, but even more than that, they cement the Washington system as one of the highest differences in the game. There is a wide range of potential outcomes for Hassell, Wood, Susanna and some of the players already in place, such as recently selected top players Elijah Green and Brady House, as well as the best international, Krisian Vakeru. The Nationals’ reputation for developing players has declined in recent years. Helping a few players above “click” will go a long way in reversing this slide.

Leave a Comment